We all know that devout Swifties are falling head over heels for Taylor Swift’s Midnights album. But what are the first impressions of a non-Swiftie?

My friend, a non-Swiftie who doesn’t regularly listen to Taylor Swift’s music, rated the following 14 Midnights songs out of 10, after listening to 15 seconds of the chorus section of each song. The results are:

1. Lavender Haze: 6
2. Maroon: 4
3. Anti-Hero: 8
4. Snow on the Beach: 5
5. You’re On Your Own, Kid: 5
6. Midnight Rain: 6
7. Question…?: 6
8. Vigilante: 9
9. Bejeweled: 4
10. Labyrinth: 3
11. Karma: 5
12. Sweet Nothing: 3
13. Mastermind: 2
14. Would’ve, Could’ve, Should’ve: 8

3 Favorite Songs: Anti Hero; Vigilante; Would’ve, Could’ve, Should’ve

3 Least Favorite Songs: Labyrinth, Sweet Nothing, Mastermind

Listen to Midnights here.

Want to know what a Swifty thinks of the new album? Read here!